Four Reasons Why the Virgin Mary Deserves More Attention in Protestant Churches

virginmaryIn the tiny Texas town where I grew up, a Bible-belted and beer-banned community, the virgin Mary had her annual fifteen minutes of fame when December rolled around. You had your shepherds, your angels, and your young maiden kneeling beside the swaddled babe. But after the presents were unwrapped and the nativity brouhaha had quieted down, Mary drifted back into the shadows once more. Why the Catholics made such a big deal about her never made sense to my Baptist mind. Yes, of course, she had a sweet, heart-warming part to play in the Jesus story, but, to me anyway, she was merely a minor character.

My appreciation for Mary’s place in the Gospel story has changed significantly over the years. When I became a Lutheran, I was introduced to the early church fathers, who opened my eyes to see how Mary’s place in the story of salvation was far from a footnote. I delved more deeply into the Scriptures to discover amazing parallels between Eve and Mary. I pondered the Incarnation, the fact that God became man inside Mary’s womb, and grasped more fully that Mary was indeed the mother of God. All of this has led me to understand a bit more about why the Catholics make such a big deal about her. And although I believe my Catholic friends say more of Mary than can be biblically justified, I also believe that many of my Protestant friends say less of Mary than the Bible demands.

Here are four truths about the virgin Mary that I wish would find a prominent place in more Protestant pulpits, songs, and classrooms. Each of them, by telling us more about Mary, actually tell us more about Jesus, and our saving relationship with Him.

1. Mary is the mother of God. The baby who was miraculously conceived in this virgin’s womb is the Son of our heavenly Father. As such, Jesus shares His Father’s nature, even as my human son shares my human nature. Jesus is fully divine; He is not only Lord and Savior but God. Now if Jesus is God, and Mary is the mother of Jesus, then Mary is the mother of God. It’s that profoundly simple. No other woman had been, was, or ever will be God’s mother except this Israelite virgin. If we say less of Mary, then we say less of Jesus, for if we are not willing to confess that she is the mother of God, then we cannot confess Jesus is God. And if Jesus is not God, then His saving work is insufficient to save us, and we are lost. It is therefore the best of news that Mary is God’s mother, because that means we are the Father’s children in Jesus Christ.

2. Mary is the first person to be one flesh with God. John says that the Word became flesh and dwelt among us (John 1:14). The Word, the Son of God, was embodied inside Mary. Everything human about Him derived from His mother. She was literally one flesh with God. Divinity not only dwelt in her, like God did in the temple’s Holy of Holies, but in the deepest part of her being she was united to God. As such, she was the first person to share this most intimate union with the Savior. But—and this is vitally important—she not the last. For we who partake of His body and blood in the Lord’s Supper are united with Him in the most intimate of unions as well. We are bodied and blooded with Him, one flesh with God, even as He became one flesh with us. In Mary, therefore, we see what the Father desires for all of us, and provides for all of us in the Supper of His Son.

3. Mary is the model hearer of the Word. When the archangel Gabriel appears to Mary to tell her she will be the mother of the Messiah, that God Himself will become incarnate in her womb, she responds, “Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word,” (Luke 1:38). She does not put forth a string of rational arguments against such a preposterous claim. She acknowledges her place as a servant of the Lord. She takes God’s messenger at his word for it is the divine word he utters. She knows that God cannot lie, so anything He promises is true and trustworthy, even if it seems irrational or downright crazy to the human mind. As such, Mary is a model hearer of the word of God, who shows us as Christians how we are to receive the divine message. God speaks, we hear, we believe, we confess with Mary, “I am a servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.”

4. Mary is like a new and better Eve. When our first mother ate of the forbidden fruit, her sin was not one of consumption but of rejection. When the fallen angel twisted God’s words, she believed his lie and so disbelieved divine truth. Her rejection of the word, as well as her husband’s rejection, ushered sin and death into our world. Yet to Eve God gave the promise that her seed would crush the head of the serpent, even as the serpent would strike that seed’s heel (Genesis 3:15). Mary is like a new and better Eve in two ways. First, when the angel spoke God’s words to her, she believed. Her reception of that word was the reception of the Word Himself, who became flesh inside her, thereby initiating His ministry of ushering forgiveness and life into our world. Second, Mary was the “Eve” who bore that promised seed, who crushed the power of our ancient foe, even as the venom of death struck that seed in His crucifixion death. Indeed, if any woman should have the name Eve, it should be Mary, for the Hebrew word for Eve means “mother of life.” And such Mary is, for she gives birth to the Savior who is the way, the truth, and the life for us.

These four reasons for Mary’s importance in the Scriptures could be multiplied. And I encourage you to add your own thoughts (or objections) in the comment section below. If you haven’t given much thought to the Virgin, or thought that was only a Catholic thing to do, or fear that such attention to Mary will distract from Jesus, then I encourage you to reconsider.

To talk about Mary is to talk about Jesus. To give our attention to Mary is to give even greater attention to Jesus. What Mary shows us, again and again, is that the child she bore is the Son of God, who became one with us, dies for us, and rises on our behalf, that in Him we have life in abundance with the Father. The good news about Mary is the Good News of Christ.

Follow me on Twitter @birdchadlouis
You may also “like” my Facebook writings page

christ alone cover

What we need in our fragmented world, full of hurting people, is the love of Jesus Christ, who InfantPriestfrontcoverwelcomes home sinners with a grace that knows no bounds. My book Christ Alone: Meditations and Sermons, is packed with reflections that go that extra mile of grace. Again and again, they present the Christ who is crucified and risen for you. Please take a moment to check it out here. You may also be interested in my collections of hymns and poetry entitled, The Infant Priest, which you can purchase here. Both books are also available on Amazon, as is my booklet Why Lutherans Sing What They Sing (also on Kindle). Thank you for your prayers and support!


Single Post Navigation

17 thoughts on “Four Reasons Why the Virgin Mary Deserves More Attention in Protestant Churches

  1. Even Mary knew her place as a humble vessel “Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word,” (Luke 1:38). She was chosen by God, the Father to give birth to God, the Son. She was significant, indeed, but was no more important than any other person who was and is chosen by God. I believe she had the humbleness of spirit and the willingness to carry out what God had ordained for her. Surely she is someone to be admired and loved because of all her virtues but to place her in some kind of holy hierarchy above the God who chose her is dangerously blasphemous. Therein lies the age old theological problem between Catholics and Protestants.

    Protestants do not pray to Mary, Mother of God. We believe our only advocate is Jesus Christ. To blur the lines between mother and Son is a confusion that leads to idolatry. As for me, I will keep Jesus Christ in His rightful place in the Trinity and revere Mary for the woman she was in the events that made that happen.

  2. Stephen C. Dawson on said:

    Why can’t forward this to my Facebook page?

  3. Are your books available through any of the Christian book distributors? I would like to be able to have it at the bookstore where I work. Spring Arbor, Send the Light or Anchor.

  4. Chad, I don’t think the one flesh language in your second point works. Jesus certainly fully shares our nature, though without sin, but “one flesh” is usually reserved for the union of man and wife. I’ve not heard it used to describe the relation between mother and child. Perhaps we might use one flesh when talking about Christ and his Bride, the Church, but I wouldn’t use it for the relationship between an individual Christian and Jesus.

    • Thank you, Scott. I had in mind the language of 1 Corinthians 10:16, “Is not the cup of blessing which we bless a communion [koinonia] in the blood of Christ? Is not the bread which we break a communion in the body of Christ?” Also 1 Corinthians 6:15, “Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ?” And if the church is the body of Christ, and we individually are members of her, then we too are one flesh with our divine Husband.

  5. Since Jesus and the Father are one (being of one substance) and God is eternal, how could God have a mother? What is wrong with Theotokos?

    • Allan,
      That’s a great question and gets to the heart of who Jesus is. I guess I’d first point out that the Scriptures themselves call Mary the mother of the Lord (Luke 1:43), so the mother of God simply parallels that. Secondly, Theotokos means God-bearer, that is, one who gives birth to God. So indeed Mary is the Theotokos, the mother who bore God. And, lastly, and most importantly, even though Jesus and the Father are one in substance, only the Son assumed our human nature. So we don’t say the Father was born or the Spirit was crucified; we say that only of the Son, because being born and dying are things that can only happen to a human. Yet since the Son is fully divine, that is, God, what we say of the Son we say also of God. So we can say that God was born, God ate and drank, God died and rose again, because Jesus did all those things, and Jesus is God. Therefore, when we say Mary is the mother of God, we are not so much saying anything about her as we are about her Son. If Mary is not the mother of God, then Jesus is not God. And if Jesus is not God, we are lost.

      I hope that provides some clarification. Thanks for the comment!

      • Jesus Acevedo on said:

        Chad you hit the nail right on the head and there is no argument to that. And also exclaim Mary was free of Sin. God cannot be where there is sin hence what is the significance of Mary, She is Free of sin; She is blessed beyond any woman and only Jesus as man can be more blessed than her becuase she bore him. But lets also add she was free to choose and she chose the must difficult of paths to bare God the Savior.

      • God cannot be where there is sin? “…he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.” (2 Co 5:21) God the Son became sin and we (including Mary) became as righteous as the Son.

  6. It does clarify things for me; thanks

  7. I am a catholic an receantly bought your book of meditation ,and just recived today I was surprised that you are Luteran, I take the of the name of the of one of the EWTN programs I used to watch.So I decided to find more about you, before star reading it.And found you article about the Virgin Mary , it make me very happy reading is what we have in our hearts.
    Thanks so much ans sorry about my english.

  8. Jesus Acevedo on said:

    If she is free of sin then she is holy and Jesus was in a Holy Place the Womb of Mary.

  9. Theresa on said:

    I am very glad to see you address the importance of Mary in our lives. She was important to Jesus, so she should not be any less so to us.
    I have to set the record straight on what lensgirl53 said. Catholics DO NOT place Mary above or even equal to God. In fact, we would consider that sinful. She is honored and loved as the mother of Christ.
    We do not pray to Mary to answer our prayers. We ask her to pray for us. Big difference! Do you ask your friends on earth to pray for you? Then why not one who you know is in heaven and is favored by God? We pray to God, but we also ask Mary for her prayers, too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: